YoshiKart64
Well Known GateFan
Indeed. You can't get more SGA iconic than McKay! Other than perhaps Sheppard, but they're probably at the same level.
Although I must say A LOT more people would be tuning in just to see Joe Flanigan, especially the ladies
I think you overestimate his pulling power, I'd wager Mckay was the more popular character. In fact I half wonder if he's become more popular in our circle due to his anti-SGU approach.
No offense intended to hardcore Flanigan fans but I've never thought he was that good an actor outside of playing Sheppard. That might well be down to it being the only decent role he's been given in quite a while. I'd certainly enjoy him showing up in SGU though, the darker side of Sheppard (seen in Season 4) never really came to fruition and this would be the perfect place to showcase that.
Of course bar some Brad Wright miracle, his Stargate canon will be ending soon so any hope of seeing my favorite characters interact is slim.