I was going to bold certain parts of this post but then realized the whole thing deserved to be bolded because it's all true. Inara, you've distilled the man's character and motivations down to two perfect paragraphs. I couldn't add a thing.
Danke, m'dear.
I've been following his commentaries since long before the fiasco over the cancellation of SGA in favor of starting SGU. It became clear that he was using his own personal Squee Squad as a way to promote himself first, using the show as his hook. He would "reward" fans who agreed with him, so they were more likely to agree with him in the future and ignore rather obvious transgressions, or worse, blame the person/group he was attacking.
It was sort of strange watching this as it happened in the early days, because I couldn't believe people were siding with a member of TPTB just because they were TPTB. But then I came into fandom at a time when TPTB were only vaguely aware of fannish discussion, and in general most fans were in the "You don't talk about Fight Club" mode, so I guess I was actually bothered by one of TPTB trying to play in the fannish sandbox and making fans feel like they had to take sides. Don't get me wrong, interaction with TPTB can be good. Answer fannish questions and the like, but don't put yourself out there as the UberFanGodKing just because you work for the show. His answers were often
his opinion, but were treated as canon by many even if another TPTB or an actor said something different. I tried to stop watching the train wreck, but it just won't go away. Stargate is dead, even the two-season spawn, but Mallozzi just won't shut the hell up.
Looking back on it, I think he was trying to build a cult of personality for himself. He wanted to get automatic fannish recognition and respect, like Joss Whedon generally gets. The Joss earned his rep, Mallozzi didn't; he's a loud little pissant with delusions of grandeur. I don't agree with every storyline choice Whedon's made (Tara!
), but in the end I felt he respected my opinion as a viewer and didn't try to justify what he was doing by bashing those who didn't like the choices.
Mallozzi needs to learn to follow the sage words of someone who went through fannish scorn in his early years to later earning and downright
owning his Geek Cred,
Wil Wheaton: "Don't be a dick!"