I only like him as Data (a la TNG). He was definitely annoying as Lore, annoying as Soong, but somewhat acceptable...IN THE CONTEXT OF DEFINING
DATA. I did not like the addition of the "emotion chip" or the creation of B4 in the Nemesis movie. But I did like his snarky interactions with the Borg Queen.
If he isnt going to be Data before he was disassembled, then who cares? Meh.
I agree about Independence Day. He was great! I think he would be a natural for the Professor in a Back To The Future remake.